Whites Valley

Whites Valley, located northwest of Tremonton, would be the site of a 170,000-acre reservoir under Utah’s proposed Bear River water project. While state officials say this project is need to meet future demand for water in northern Utah, critics believe diverting the Bear would irrevocably harm Great Salt Lake.

Support Local Journalism

Outside the northern Utah town of Tremonton, undeveloped lands sit against the West Hills, rolling out toward Idaho. In the coming decades, these hills may also harbor one of Utah’s largest reservoirs, filling a place called Whites Valley with water that would feed urban growth along the Wasatch Front.

Whites Valley is shaping up to be the linchpin of Utah’s massive proposed Bear River Water Development Project, which would store as much as 220,000 acre-feet of water a year for four northern Utah water districts.

Candice Hasenyager, director of the Utah Division of Water Resources, highlighted this component of the billion-dollar-plus project earlier this month before a legislative appropriations subcommittee.

The water won’t be needed for decades, but the division is laying the groundwork for planning and acquisition of land and rights of way. When the project was initially authorized by the Legislature in 1991, it was assumed the water would be needed by 2015.

“But because of water conservation efforts, reducing our water use, implementing secondary meters [on untreated water used for landscaping], that need has been pushed off to 2050,” Hasenyager said. “There is definitely a phasing need. The whole complete project is not needed at 2050. That’s when the need starts appearing.”

Environmentalists and other critics contend the project would not only be a fiscal drag on the water districts receiving the water and that it would threaten the Great Salt Lake. These massive water diversions would never be needed if Utah got more aggressive about reducing water use and smarter about managing its water resources, according to Zach Frankel, executive director of the Utah Rivers Council.

“Bear River Development is a welfare project for water lobbyists and contractors. There is no need for Bear River water on the Wasatch Front. Period,” Frankel said. “We are such wasteful secondary water users. We don’t even have any idea how much water people are using, much less making sure they’re paying appropriately for it.”

The state has only just begun installing meters on the secondary water systems in northern Utah, and officials plan to step up these efforts using federal infrastructure grants. Currently, residents and businesses pay a flat annual rate for secondary water they apply to their landscaping, and most have no idea how much they use. Studies show that Utah residents cut their use of secondary water by 20 to 30% if they are simply informed how much they use.

That suggests water needs would plummet if secondary water were always metered and users were required to pay a rate tied to their level of use, Frankel argued.

This article is published through the Utah News Collaborative, a partnership of news organizations in Utah that aim to inform readers across the state. To read the full article, click here.

Please be aware that Cache Valley Publishing does not endorse, and is not responsible for alleged employment offers in the comments.

Recommended for you